July42012

Conversation from RobertLovesPi's classroom, yesterday, accurate to the best of my recollection. I'm trying to teach them the importance of skepticism, and that isn't easy -- but it is very much worth it.

  • Prelude: During classroom discussion, astronomy came up in my high school Geometry class, while discussing the shapes of planetary orbits, and how they differ from true circles.
  • RobertLovesPi (me): Now, this is astronomy we're talking about. I do hope all of you know the difference between that, and that . . . thing . . . called astrology. Do you?
  • Student A: What's the difference?
  • Me: Astronomy is a real science, makes sense, and works. Astrology is, well, bunk. And, if I weren't in school, and none of you were around, I would use FAR stronger language. Astrology is that stuff they print in newspapers -- you know, horoscopes and such.
  • Student B (who is very bright -- I can tell this already, even though she has only been my student for about a week -- Summer School moves quickly): I love to read my horoscope!
  • Me: Please don't do that anymore. You're insulting your own brain when you do so, and training it to accept things which make no sense.
  • Student B: What do you mean?
  • Me: Well, try reading the horoscope for some other sign some time, and you'll see that a lot of things there apply to you, as well.
  • Student C: He's right.
  • Me: They do this by making a lot of vague statements, designed to sound good to anyone. Let me ask you this: have you ever had a bad day?
  • Several students: Yes.
  • Me: So have I. Have you ever seen a horoscope that told people they would have a bad day?
  • The whole class: [after a moment of silence] Um, no....
  • Me: Let's take this one step forward. Do people ever die?
  • Several students: Yes.
  • Me: Well, do you think their horoscopes mentioned, on those days, that they were going to die? Their horoscopes were certainly wrong on THOSE days, were they not?
  • The class as a whole: [silent looks of bewilderment]
  • Postscript: This exchange only took a minute or so, and we then returned to the pure geometry of circles, so I could SHOW them why pi has the value it has, and not simply expect them to accept it on the basis of an argument from authority -- in this case, with me being the authority figure I do not want them to trust without question. To teach in any other way would violate very ethical principle I accept. I also had to put much effort into obliterating the lies they had previously learned about my favorite number, for many of them have been taught that pi = 3.14. It doesn't, of course. The tattoo of pi on my arm was helpful in this regard.
  • Closing thoughts: Yesterday was a very good day in class. Much was accomplished. Teachers like me LIVE for days like this.
May62012

Radiohead

“I Might Be Wrong”

Kid A

1PM
1PM
“The truth is there is no Islamic army or terrorist group called Al-Qaeda. Any informed intelligence officer knows this. But there is a propaganda campaign to make the public believe in the presence of an identified entity representing the “devil” only in order to drive TV watchers to accept a unified international leadership for a war against terrorism. The country behind this propaganda is the United States.” Former foreign British secretary, Robin Cook (via skaterboytae)
February132012

Fiction and Satirical Works of Interest to Atheists

I’ve seen a lot of non-fiction book recommendations on lackofbelief, but not as many fiction or satirical works. Cat’s Cradle by Kurt Vonnegut is a wonderful example of a religious satire, while still bringing elements of science. I’m not terribly good at writing reviews/submissions, so Robert/Marriah can rewrite this as they please.

[Above:  a submission — thank you!]

I’d like to simply add a few others:

  • Ambrose Bierce, The Devil’s Dictionary (satire)
  • Robert Heinlein, Job (religious fiction from a science-fiction author)
  • Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid’s Tale (dystopian novel about an America in which the relgious right has complete control)
  • Flannery O’Connor’s short stories 

Flannery O’Connor is an interesting case.  She’s my (RobertLovesPi’s) favorite fiction author, and was also a devout Catholic until death, as well as a Southerner.  Many of her stories feature religion, and religious characters … but are about such things as hypocrisy, and the various depths of human depravity, especially under the guise of religion.  Some atheists avoid her because they know she was a devout Catholic, but this would be a mistake, in my opinion.  O’Connor was a thinker.

February112012
Here’s an example of how much of a skeptic I am when it comes to astrology:  this was on my Tumblr dashboard, but, not wanting to traumatize me, my brain apparently, subconsciously changed “Scorpios” to “scorpions,” so I thought I was reading about dangerous arthropods … and was then getting more and more confused … then “zodiaccity” threw me for a loop … and not until I read the comment below did I actually get that this is an astrology post.  That’s how little regard I have for astrology.    —RobertLovesPi
4chan-makes-me-moist:

THERE’S MORE
i love having two star signs.

Here’s an example of how much of a skeptic I am when it comes to astrology:  this was on my Tumblr dashboard, but, not wanting to traumatize me, my brain apparently, subconsciously changed “Scorpios” to “scorpions,” so I thought I was reading about dangerous arthropods … and was then getting more and more confused … then “zodiaccity” threw me for a loop … and not until I read the comment below did I actually get that this is an astrology post.  That’s how little regard I have for astrology.    —RobertLovesPi

4chan-makes-me-moist:

THERE’S MORE

i love having two star signs.

(via drifbl00n)

January282012

Atheist Anthems

[Thank you — I will check it out!]

I saw your post about Atheist Anthems, and figured I’d point out that “Real World” by Gamma Ray, is a perfect example of one.

2PM
Posted by RobertLovesPi, who has been annoying students (and others) with this answer for many years.

Posted by RobertLovesPi, who has been annoying students (and others) with this answer for many years.

8AM

Confession: Sometimes when I’m asked, “What are the possibilities of that happening?” I play out scenarios like this in my head

I’ve been utterly irrational at various points in my life, and I don’t want to back to a state like that.  I suspect that (almost?) all atheists could honestly say that, especially by my age (44, also known as “Tumblr old”).

Of course, there are atheists of various types, including those who are also really into math and/or science, like me (RobertLovesPi).  Judging from this cartoon alone, I would have guessed that Kim (the original poster of this) can also be described this way.  You can see her comments (and more of mine) below the cartoon.  (Hi, Kim!)

nonplussedbyreligion:

I’ve embraced my inner nerd.  Fortunately I usually start and end in the last panel, but I’ve been known to go off on wild ones.  The more asinine the event being questioned, the more elaborate my hypothesis. ~ Kim

[RobertLovesPi again]:  The sad truth is that I still, even after becoming an atheist, sometimes do things that break right out of “thought-balloons,” and are not too different from this.  I have tested the hypothesis (once I realize it was a hypothesis, I became obsessed with conducting the experiment immediately) that one can made an unstable, large star go supernova (centuries in the past, mind you, so that we’d be able to see it quickly after the experiment began, for stars are far away) by posting pictures of the star on the Internet, combined with a lot of wishful thinking.  I watched for 24 hours (the window I had set for testing) for the Betelgeuse supernova, an event I have awaited all my life, and babbled about it on multiple sites.  I was relieved when the results (no supernova in allotted window of time) proved that I possessed no such power.

I’ve also only recently abandoned elaborate plans for real physical immortality.  It took years for me to realize that such things as (for example) the Second Law of Thermodynamics make immortality, with any technology that can ever exist, literally impossible.  I was an utterly devoted believer in immortality (motivated by severe thanatophobia, an irrational and extreme fear of death), with my multi-staged and (I realize now) crazy scheme in place, and I really believed I had a shot at avoiding the Grim Reaper.  Forever.

I don’t want to believe anything.  VoluptuousAtheist and I discussed the name of this blog at its inception, and its title, “Lack of Belief,” is related to this.  It just doesn’t make sense to believe things.  History and modern life contain countless examples that demonstrate this principle, and you’re probably thinking (I am guessing) of the set you know yourself, right now.  It makes sense to accept things for which there is evidence, such as that provided by the scientific method or mathematical proof.  I only want to accept things for which there are rational reasons for such acceptance.  I want none of the “beliefs.”

To be skeptical, for me, is to preserve, and hopefully strengthen, what sanity I do possess.  This is a bigger issue than theism vs. atheism, and it certainly is not limited to Christianity.  You’ll find posts here about many other religions, and about things that are not religions at all, such as homeopathy, astrology, and many other things people “believe in” without rational reasons.

Having fallen over the edge of unreason in various ways before, and somehow survived relatively intact, I try to keep my bullshit detector turned on, 24/7.  It’s aimed at everyone, especially myself.

 ”The first rule is that you must not fool yourself — and you are the easiest person to fool.” —Richard Feynman

(Source: abstrusegoose.com, via )

January162012
“Regarding the 1962 U.S. Supreme Court decision prohibiting state-supported prayer in public schools: “…sound and good, reaffirming something basic in the Nation’s life: separation of church and state.” Martin Luther King Jr - American civil rights activist.  One of the most iconic figures in American history that advocated nonviolence as the method to achieve equal rights.  Youngest person to receive the Nobel Peace Prize.  King was assassinated in 1968. (via helvetebrann)

(via voluptuousatheist-deactivated20)

December262011
December212011

I have met James Randi, a skeptic who has put his money where his lack of beliefs are.  He’s quite the character, as you can see in this video.

The upshot:  if anyone can demonstrate, under controlled laboratory conditons, ANY supernatural ability, Randi has $1,000,000.00 waiting for them.  This video showcases Randi’s debunking of psychics, but his challenge is not limited to them — if you can walk on water, or turn water into wine, go get rich!

[posted to lackofbelief by Robertlovespi]

November302011
“Religion was invented when the first con man met the first fool.” Happy birthday to Mark Twain - American writer, journalist, and humorist.  Author of the strongly anti-religious Letters from the Earth and The Lowest Animal, as well as the famous Huckleberry Finn and Tom Sawyer.  His voluminous anti-religious writings have been collected in a volume titled The Bible According to Mark Twain. (via helvetebrann)
November282011

helvetebrann:

Remember this girl?  Guess who I ran into tonight at a teacher event?  That’s right, her.  What do you think I did?

Did I:

A) Tell her off?

B) Ignore her?

C) Flip her off?

D) Smile, say hello, walk off?

If you answered D, you’ve won tonight’s quiz.  But why Tiffany, you may ask.  Why on Earth would you be polite to someone who is clearly so wrong?

My dears, the “teacher” that I used to be friends with made the wrong decision.  She abused her position of power, she bragged about her influence on Facebook, and she deleted me when I called her on it.  I followed through and anonymously reported it to her school.  As far as I’m concerned, I see no reason to be rude to her. 

I saw her at a function in town for teachers, which will probably happen again in the future.  I didn’t pretend to make conversation or to be friendly, but I also didn’t ignore her.  She’s still a human being.  And you know what?  Maybe, just maybe, smiling and saying hello in passing will help her realize that I was the one acting more like her supposed Christ than her.  Who knows, maybe she got home and realized in shame how childish and immature she acted?  You never know.

I’d rather be a positive influence on the people around me rather than a negative influence. 

November192011
← Older entries Page 1 of 2